Court hearings, applications, and in-person court conferences at all levels of British Columbia courts have been cancelled or postponed. New matters coming before the courts are greatly reduced at this time. There is however the opportunity for “urgent” matters still to be dealt with. Please call us if you are wondering about the status of your matter. Likewise, please call us to see if your unique matter or issue is “urgent enough”, in the eyes of the court.
The Supreme Court of British Columbia has handed down a favourable decision for our client, preventing the relocation of his children from Aldergrove, BC to Stonewall, MB.
Reasonable and Workable Arrangements – BC Family Law Act
Judge Saunders explained that “any relocation case must be focused on the “best interests” of the child.” He went on to add that, where parenting time is substantially unequal, such cases normally have also considered the factors of “good faith” and “reasonable and workable arrangements” set out in s. 69(4)(a) of the Family Law Act. However, Judge Saunders reasoned that examining the latter two factors was only necessary where the considerations are “evenly balanced” between allowing and disallowing the relocation. Therefore, if the best interests of the child is very one-sided, the court may focus solely on the best interests issue and need not assess the factors of good faith and the proposed parenting time arrangements.
S. 211 Views of the Child Report
Evidence submitted through the s. 211 Views of the Child Report, prepared by Mr. Robert Finlay – where the children confirmed a preference not to move and close relationships with both our client and his family – was seen to support our client’s evidence. Factors for our client to overcome included the facts that the mother had the bulk of parenting time, and that he had engaged in some family violence toward the mother and in some poor anger management towards the mother and stepfather. The court ultimately decided however that our client’s strong relationship with his children, especially his son where hockey was a central bonding factor, and the children’s very close relationships with their extended family outweighed the other factors. Relocation of the children to another province would have adversely affected their current relationships with their father and family members, thus relocation was not in the best interests of the children.
Parental Rights BC
To discuss your child relocation matter and parental rights with our family lawyer, Graham C. Laschuk, please call (604) 948-7200 for an initial consultation.
Read about our Family Law Agreement Services
Supplements to this case
Read the judgement in its entirety https://www.canlii.org/en/bc/bcsc/doc/2019/2019bcsc75/2019bcsc75.html
Download the PDF
Judge Saunders, re D.T.F. v. K.S., 01-24